Chelsea Football Club Settles Case with Doctor Eva Carneiro

Chelsea Football Club Settles Case with Doctor Eva Carneiro

- June 13, 2016

Chelsea Football Club and former team doctor Eva Carneiro have reached a settlement, reportedly worth £5 million. Carneiro had initially turned down a £1.2m settlement with Chelsea, before the club upped the settlement offer behind closed doors.

Chelsea also released an apology to Carneiro over the situation that found Jose Mourinho to have been accused of sexism. Interestingly, the man at the eye of the storm, Mourinho, did not issue any kind of an apology to Carneiro.

Chelsea said in a statement: “The club regrets the circumstances which led to Dr Carneiro leaving the club and apologises unreservedly to her and her family for the distress caused.

“We wish to place on record that in running onto the pitch Dr Carneiro was following both the rules of the game and fulfilling her responsibility to the players as a doctor, putting their safety first.”

Who is Dr Eva Carneiro?

Carneiro joined English Premier League club Chelsea in 2009, working with the club’s reserve squad. Two years later, Carneiro was promoted to work with the first team under Chelsea manager Andre Villas-Boas. Despite the managerial changes at the West London club, Carneiro remained as the first team doctor.

Even before the sexism row with Mourinho, Carneiro had been the subject of opposition fans. Several of Chelsea’s biggest rivals’ supporters were accused of sexist chants toward the doctor during matches.

What happened at Chelsea FC?

At the beginning of the 2015-16 season, Carneiro was highly criticised by Chelsea manager Mourinho during a match versus Swansea City. Mourinho became irate when Carneiro went on to the pitch to check on Eden Hazard after he had gone down with an injury. Mourinho criticised her for running on to the pitch so eagerly, and didn’t feel the injury to Hazard was serious enough to need medical treatment.

Carneiro stated that Mourinho called her a “daughter of a whore”, in Portuguese as she ran on to the pitch. The phrase is an extremely provocative remark in the Portuguese language. After the incident at Stamford Bridge, Carneiro did not appear on Chelsea’s bench again, and soon after left the club.

In an act to take the building heat off of Jose Mourinho and the English Premier League, the English Football Association cleared Mourinho of using discriminatory language toward Carneiro.

Chelsea FC in court

During the hearing, Carneiro was expected to take the witness stand and expose emails and text messages she had received from Mourinho and other members of the club’s hierarchy. The revelations were to be explosive and cause embarrassment on the club and Mourinho.

With the chance for embarrassment in a public form, a settlement was reached, keeping the explosive statements hidden for now.

Chelsea’s defence had been to drag Carniero’s name through the mud, making her out to be a money and fame hungry woman. Yet, once Carneiro threatened to spill the truth on the club and Mourinho,now at Manchester United, the club changed tact.

Legacy of the Carneiro case

Carneiro, a role model for young women to stand up for their rights and to pursue a career in a predominantly men’s game, will most likely leave the limelight of the football world.

Mourinho on the other hand, takes over the reins at Manchester United, seemingly unscathed from the case. Manchester United were also keen that the case involving their new manager and the former Chelsea doctor was taken care of. His reputation is still intact, for now, as the English media continue to be enamoured with the “Special One.” 

Brodey Sheppard

Brodey Sheppard

Brodey Sheppard’s interest in keeping up with the ‘bleeding edge’ of technology has kept him working in the digital marketing industry for over six years. Aside from searching for opportunities to increase his online marketing knowledge, Sam also scours the Internet for useful bonuses and coupon codes that he can use to fuel his love for photography. During his free time, he watches professional photo retouching tutorials in between streaming his favourite TV shows. Fun fact: Sam has never met a cupcake he didn't like.